Real Men Sow

Trying Stumpy Carrot Varieties for Stony Soil

Have you ever found yourself growing the same varieties of a vegetable every year, with limited success, yet never trying another one?

Well, I have. This has been my attitude with carrots, right from the very start. I’ve grown Early Nantes and Autumn King – nothing else, and no questions asked.

I don’t really know why. They just seemed to be the ones that everyone said were reliable and easy. All the seed catalogues had glowing testimonies to their greatness. Maybe another reason was their bountiful availability. Every magazine and newspaper seemed happy to dish out free Early Nantes and Autumn King at the start of the season. I’ve got packets and packets of them.

Good Rude Shaped Carrots, Poor Eating Ones
I’ve never really succeeded with these carrots. I’d guess this is to do with my stony soil, which forces the carrots to split every time they encounter something in the soil I have the same problem with parsnips. Its brilliant for comedy phallic veg, not so for big, strong and tasty carrots.

Early Scarlet Horn
However, this year, a gardening chum handed me a packet of Early Scarlet Horn, and finally I’ve been inspired to try something different.

The Early Scarlet Horn carrot originates from the town of Hoorn in the Netherlands, and were common on the Amsterdam market in 1610. On inspection of the seed packet, they look short and stubby, which led me to wonder whether a dumpy carrot would do better in stony soils.

A quick check on the Unwins website confirms that ‘if your soil is heavy, stony or shallow, this is the variety for you!

The soil in my garden is both stony and heavy, so these baby carrots sound just the job. I may have to grow twice as many, but they do look tantalisingly sweet.

Two More to Try
Other varieties I have stumbled upon which look useful and intriguing for us stony soilers are the spherical Parmex and Paris Market.

Parmex are a rounded, bite-sized carrot, and like the Horn, is early maturing. Thompson and Morgan suggest them ideal for growing in containers, and state the short roots cope well with clay soils.

Paris Market are also recommended for heavy soil and containers, and feature heavily by Naomi Schillinger from Out of My Shed in her forthcoming book, Veg Street.

With an increasing interest in container growing, and heavier soil than I was used to at the allotment, all three of these varieties are very tempting.

I’ve sown some Early Scarlet Horn in a container in the greenhouse, while I await delivery of a packet of Parmex.

I feel rather liberated to move away from the standard carrot varieties and try something else. I’m sure I’ll still try a few Early Nantes and Autumn King, but growing the shorter carrots will provide a useful little comparison once the season gets going properly.

Tagged , , , ,

Related Posts

Sign up to receive a RMS weekly bite size summary, featuring all posts from the previous seven days, hints and tips and other interesting snippets from the world of veg growing.


  1. Mark NFebruary 22, 2013 at 4:02 pmReply

    I grew ESH last year. Very tasty and they came out a fair bit bigger than the pictures on the packet. I think you’ll like them.

  2. Jono

    JonoFebruary 22, 2013 at 6:03 pmReplyAuthor

    Thanks Mark. Interesting to know they get bigger too. Looking forward to a good crop hopefully.

    They don’t get woody as they get bigger do they?

  3. Mark NFebruary 22, 2013 at 7:47 pmReply

    Mine didn’t seem to. I mainly grow stumpy varieties of carrot, although this year (much like you in reverse) I’ve gone for some bigger ones. Good luck.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published.

About Real Men Sow

meIn 2007, I took on a redundant allotment plot with my gardening-mad mum Jan. As all good mums do, she went along with it, but I don’t think she held out much hope. However, over a decade later, and she now lets me do stuff without watching over my shoulder, so I must be doing something right. [ read more ]

Buy My Book on Amazon!


Sign Here for Updates!

Sign up to receive a regular RMS bite size summary, featuring all recent posts, hints and tips and other interesting snippets from the world of veg growing.

Allotment Cakes for the Weekend

  • Allotment Cakes for the Weekend #15 – Blackberry and Apple Flapjack
  • Allotment Cakes for the Weekend #14 – Courgette, Lime and Coconut Cake
  • Allotment Cakes for the Weekend #13 – Jamie Oliver’s Squash Muffins
  • An Allotment Cake for the Weekend #12 – Lemon Curd & Blueberry Loaf Cake
  • An Allotment Cake For the Weekend #11 – Apple and Cinnamon Flapjacks
  • An Allotment Cake For the Weekend #10 – Fresh Ginger and Apple Cake
  • Good Food Magazine Marrow and Pecan Cake
  • A Rhubarbey Roundup, and Whatever Happened to Allotment Cakes for the Weekend?

Saving £500 a year!

During 2011, I kept a diary of how much money I save from growing my own fruit and vegetables. After totalling all my outgoings, I saved approximately £500 over the year. I made a spreadsheet to calculate these savings - it’s nothing too complicated, as I’m no Excel guru, but hopefully someone else will find it as useful (and strangely fun) as me. For more info, visit my Money Saving Experiment page by clicking here.


As Featured In…